Steaks & Chicken Steaks

“Classics”

  • Plain Steak
    • $6.45 $7.45
    • A classic plain steak
  • Cheese Steak
    • $6.95 $7.95
    • Our Multiple Award Winning Cheese Steak. Thank You to Philadelphia Magazine, The Philadelphia Inquirer and the Daily Local for again recognizing The Peppermill for “The Best Cheese Steak In Chester County.”
  • Pizza Steak
    • $6.95 $7.95
    • Our classic steak with provolone & Pepper Mill homemade red sauce.
  • Chicken Steak
    • $6.95 $7.95
    • The classic, but with chicken
  • Chicken Cheese Steak
    • $7.05 $8.25
    • Chicken steak with american cheese.

“Pepper Mill Originals”

  • Premier Cheese Steak
    • $8.25
    • Cut from the High Quality T-Bone, this is an especially tender and richly flavored cheese steak.
  • Triple Cheese Steak
    • $7.45 $8.45
    • A classic cheese steak on a toasted roll, smothered in provolone, mozzarella and American cheeses.
  • The Grid Iron
    • $7.45 $8.45
    • A classic pizza steak with fried onion & mushroom.
    • It’s just that good, really.
  • South of the Border
    • $7.45 $8.45
    • Chicken cheese steak w/ a rich blend of southwestern spices,fried onion and sautéed green peppers.
  • Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak
    • $7.95 $8.95
    • Chicken cheese steak, with Benny’s home made buffalo sauce & extra thick blue cheese dressing.
    • As good as our wings. . .almost.
  • Spicy Chicken Steak Cordon Bleu
    • $7.95 $8.95
    • Chicken cheese steak chopped w/ spicy capicola, and balanced by sweet and tangy honey

Pizza

At the Pepper Mill, We Take Pizza Seriously. Our sauce and dough are made in house, fresh, every day. Our Pies are always hand tossed, never pre-formed. We’ve had the same Pizza Guy and Same Recipe for over 20 years. Some things don’t change for a reason.

Small 12" $8.25 / $1.75
Large 16" $10.25 / $2.25
Sicilian $12.95 / $2.50

Pizza and Stromboli Extras
Extra Cheese, Cheddar Cheese, Ricotta, Pepperoni, Sausage, Italian Sausage, Meatballs,Virginia Baked Ham, Capicola , Hamburger, Canadian Bacon, Anchovies, Mushrooms, Broccoli, Black Olives, Green Olives, Spinach, Sweet or Hot Peppers, Fresh or Sauteed Green Peppers or Onions, Jalapeño, Pineapple, Roasted Garlic, Fresh Basil

1.5 Times Extra: Roasted Red Peppers, Sun-dried Tomato, Shrimp, Char Grilled Chicken, Steak, Chicken Steak

All Pizzas Available on “Original” or “Whole Wheat” Crust

  • Pepper Mill Classic
    • $8.25 $10.50
    • Blended mozzarella & provolone w/ homemade Pepper Mill red sauce
  • Take Five
    • $13.50 $16.95
    • Classic Pizza, five extras of your choice Five Toppings for the Price of Three!!!
  • White
    • $8.95 $11.50
    • Blended mozzarella, provolone, garlic & seasonings
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza
    • $11.95 $14.95
    • Char grilled chicken, Pepper Mill’s homemade buffalo sauce, mozzarella, & provolone (No Red Sauce)
  • Sweet Basil
    • $11.95 $14.95
    • Classic Pizza, pepperoni, roasted red pepper, fresh basil
  • The Prime
    • $13.50 $16.95
    • Classic Pizza, pepperoni, sausage, meatball, Virginia baked ham, American bacon
  • Vegetable
    • $10.95 $13.95
    • Classic Pizza, broccoli, mushroom, green pepper, onion, sliced tomato, parmesan. Try w/ Roasted Garlic!
  • Chris’ White
    • $12.95 $15.95
    • White Pizza, grilled chicken, spinach, tomato, parmesan Try on Wheat Crust!
  • Tomato Pie (18”x24”)
    • $29.00

From the Grille

All Items include Lettuce, Tomato & Onion • Add Fries for $1.50

“Classics”

  • Hamburger
    • $5.95 $8.25 $6.95
    • Lean chuck roll, ground in-house daily and char grilled to your liking
  • Cheeseburger
    • $6.50 $8.95 $7.45
    • Classic homemade hamburger, with American, Cooper sharp, swiss or provolone.
  • Grilled Chicken Breast
    • $5.95 $8.25 $6.95
    • Char grilled, with all the fixings
  • Virginia Baked Ham Melt
    • $6.95 $8.25 $7.95
    • Mild imported ham piled high with your choice of cheese and bread
  • Grilled Reuben
    • $6.95 $8.25 $7.95
    • Corned beef or pastrami, Swiss, sauerkraut and extra thick Russian dressing grilled on Rye.
  • Tuna Grill
    • $7.95
    • Home made tuna salad grilled on rye, with Swiss.
  • Grilled Cheese
    • $4.50
    • Choice of white, wheat or rye, with american cheese.
  • Super Dog
    • $3.95
    • Jumbo hot dog, char grilled, juicy inside and crispy outside. Add Cheese or Bacon: $.95 ea.
  • Pork Roll
    • $4.95
    • Classic pork roll on a bun. Add Cheese: $.95 ea.

“Pepper Mill Originals”

  • Arizona Burger
    • $6.95 $8.95 $7.45
    • Our classic burger topped with virginia baked ham, southwestern spices, BBQ sauce, and cooper sharp american cheese
  • Hot and Bleu Burger
    • $6.95 $8.95 $8.45
    • Our classic burger, extra thick blue cheese & hot peppers Add Bacon: $.95
  • Grilled Veggie
    • $6.95 $6.95 $6.95
    • Fresh, grilled vegetables, cooper sharp cheese, on homemade focaccia
  • BBQ Pulled Pork
    • $6.95 $8.25 $7.95
    • Home made carolina pulled pork, served with cole slaw on a Kaiser Add Hot Peppers & American Cheese: $.95
  • Chicken Cordon Bleu
    • $6.95 $8.25 $7.95
    • Our classic fried chicken breast, with virginia baked ham, swiss and honey mustard. Served on a Kaiser
  • The New Yorker
    • $6.95 $8.25 $7.45
    • Pastrami, spicy mustard, sauerkraut, swiss, grilled on rye
  • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
    • $7.25 $8.95 $7.95
    • Crispy fried chicken breast, homemade buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, extra thick blue cheese on a kaiser
  • Firehouse Chicken Sandwich
    • $6.95 $8.25 $7.95
    • Grilled chicken breast, cajun seasoning, ranch dressing, lettuce, tomato on a kaiser
  • Premier Sandwich
    • $5.95
    • Grilled Premier Steak patty

Hoagies & Sandwiches

The Pepper Mill proudly serves home made Roast Beef, Turkey, and the highest quality Pastrami, Corned Beef, Virginia Baked Ham, Imported Ham, Capicola, Genoa & Pepperoni

Cheeses: Provolone, American, Cooper Sharp American, Shredded Mozzarella

All Hoagies Served w/ Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Oil & Vinegar & Spices

Any Hoagie can be made:
As a Grinder $.95 • As a Garlic Bread Grinder $1.50

“Classic Hoagies & Sandwiches”

  • Classic Sandwich
    • $6.95 $7.95 $7.45
    • Your choice of meat and cheese, made your way
  • Italian
    • $6.95 $7.95 $7.45
    • Pepper ham, genoa, capicola, provolone
  • American
    • $6.95 $7.95 $7.45
    • Cooked salami, pepperham, virginia baked ham, american cheese
  • Mixed Cheese
    • $5.95 $6.95 $6.95
    • Two layers each of american and provolone cheeses
  • Tuna or Chicken Salad
    • $6.95 $7.95 $7.45
    • Our homemade tuna or chicken salad
    • Add Cheese: $.95
  • Ham & Cheese
    • $6.95 $7.95 $7.45
    • Imported ham, American cheese
  • The Special
    • $6.95 $7.95 $7.45
    • Roast beef, corned beef or ham & turkey, w/cole slaw, extra thick Russian dressing
    • (No Lettuce, Onion & Tomato)
  • BLT
    • $5.95 $7.45 $6.95
    • Bacon, lettuce and tomato w/ mayo on Toast
    • Add Avocado: $.95
  • Club
    • $6.95 $7.95 $7.45
    • Your choice of deli meat, lettuce, tomato, onion, w/mayo, double stacked on Toast

“Pepper Mill Originals”

  • Italian Special
    • $7.45 $8.25 $7.95
    • Pepper ham, genoa, capicola, pepperoni, pickles, provolone
  • Southwest Turkey
    • $6.95 $7.95 $7.45
    • In house roasted turkey, cheddar, southwestern ranch, lettuce, tomato jalapeño and black olive
  • Blue Combo
    • $7.45 $8.25 $7.95
    • Genoa, turkey, imported ham, provolone & extra thick blue cheese dressing
    • A Pepper Mill Favorite
  • Roast Beef & Horseradish
    • $7.45 $8.25 $7.95
    • Rare roast beef, diced cucumber, Swiss cheese, homemade horseradish sauce
    • Add Bacon: $.95
  • Chicken Salad & Apple
    • $6.95 $7.95 $7.45
    • Chicken salad, diced apple, provolone
    • Add Bacon: $.95
  • Tuscan Turkey
    • $6.95 $7.95 $7.45
    • In house roasted turkey, pepperoni, roasted red pepper, sundried tomato, provolone

Hot Sandwiches

Any Hot Sandwich can be made: On Garlic Bread $.75 • As a Grinder $.95 • As a Garlic Bread Grinder $1.50

  • Meatball
    • $6.95
    • Italian meatballs, Pepper Mill red sauce.
    • Try on Garlic Bread!
  • Italian Sausage with Sauce
    • $6.95
    • Italian sausage, Pepper Mill red sauce. Try on Garlic Bread!
    • Sauteed Green Pepper & Onion: $.95
  • Chicago Italian Beef
    • $8.25
    • Home made slow roasted beef, Au jus, provolone cheese & roasted red peppers (or hot peppers).
  • Pepper & Egg
    • $5.95
    • Scrambled egg & sautéed green peppers.
  • Chicken Parmesan
    • $7.95
    • Sliced chicken fingers, Pepper Mill red sauce, melted mozzarella
  • Ranch Chicken Finger
    • $7.25
    • Sliced chicken fingers, ranch dressing
  • Cuban
    • $7.95
    • Spicy pulled pork, Virginia baked

Stromboli

Virtually any of our hoagies can be made into one of our famous Stromboli’s. Try your favorite hoagie as a Stromboli!

  • Cheese Steak or Chicken Cheese Steak
    • $9.95 $12.95
    • Steak, american, mozzarella, provolone
  • Chicken w/ Broccoli & Cheddar
    • $10.95 $13.95
    • Char grilled chicken, broccoli, mozzarella, provolone, cheddar
  • Pepperoni & Cheese
    • $9.95 $12.95
    • Pepperoni, provolone, mozzarella
  • Pizza
    • $9.95 $12.95
    • Mozzarella, provolone, red sauce w/choose your own extra’s from above!
  • Hot and Blue
    • $10.95 $13.95
    • Hamburger, hot peppers, extra thick blue cheese, american cheese, lettuce & tomato
  • Reuben
    • $10.95 $13.95
    • Corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss, russian dressing
  • Chicken Cordon Bleu
    • $10.95 $13.95
    • Crispy fried chicken breast, imported ham, honey mustard, swiss
  • Vegetable
    • $10.95 $13.95
    • Broccoli, mushroom, green pepper, onion, sliced tomato, mozzarella, provolone, parmesan
  • Spinach & Sweet Garlic
    • $10.95 $13.95
    • Spinach, roasted garlic, ricotta, parmesan
  • Italian
    • $10.95 $13.95
    • Peppers, ham, genoa, pepperoni, capicola, provolone, mozzarella, sauce

Salads

  • Tuna or Chicken Salad
    • $7.95
    • Homemade Tuna or Chicken Salad, sliced apple, cole slaw, hard boiled egg, tomato, over a bed of romaine lettuce
  • Greek Salad
    • $6.95
    • Romaine, feta cheese, cucumber, black olive, homemade croutons w/Balsamic Vinaigrette Add Grilled Chicken $1.95 or Grilled Shrimp $2.95
  • Caesar Salad
    • $6.95
    • Romaine, homemade dressing, homemade croutons Add Grilled Chicken $1.95 or Grilled Shrimp $2.95
  • Salad Sampler
    • $8.25
    • Chicken salad, tuna salad, pasta salad, garden salad, cole slaw, sweet peppers, pickles, hard-boiled egg, over a bed of romaine lettuce
  • Chef Salad
    • $8.25
    • Imported ham, provolone, American cheese, turkey, lettuce, tomato, sweet peppers, pickles, cole slaw, hard boiled egg, over a bed of romaine lettuce
  • Flamin’ Rooster Salad
    • $7.95
    • Chopped buffalo chicken fingers, cheddar, tomato, cucumber, hard boiled egg w/ extra thick blue cheese dressing, over iceberg lettuce
  • Wedge Salad
    • $5.95
    • Quarter head of iceberg lettuce, chopped tomato, bacon crumble, red onion, extra thick blue cheese dressing
  • Santa Fe Salad
    • $8.45
    • Southwest spiced chicken breast over iceberg, avocado, black olive, tomato, jalapeño, crispy tortilla w/ southwestern ranch dressing
    • Or Grilled Shrimp instead of chicken $1.00
  • Garden Salad
    • $5.95
    • Romaine, sliced cucumber, tomato wedge, shredded carrot, red cabbage, homemade croutons w/ choice of dressing
    • Add Grilled Chicken: $1.95 or Grilled Shrimp: $2.95
  • Cobb Salad
    • $8.95
    • Rows of romaine, grilled chicken breast, bacon, avocado, corn, hard boiled egg, blue cheese crumble, homemade sweet’n spicy cashews. w/ choice of dressing

Salad Dressing
Italian • French • Russian • Blue Cheese • Ranch • Oil & Vinegar • Roasted Red • Pepper Ranch • Raspberry Vinaigrette Good Seasons Balsamic
Extra Dressing $.50

Side Orders / Extras

French Fries / Potato Chunks $3.25 $4.50
Old Bay Spiced Fries / Cajun Spiced Fries $3.50 $4.75

Onion Rings / Breaded Zucchini / Breaded Mushrooms $3.25

Mozzarella Sticks w/Marinara / Fried Ravioli w/Marinara / Broccoli Cheddar Poppers w/Ranch / Jalapeño Poppers $4.25

Chicken Fingers w/BBQ $5.95 / Buffalo Tenders $6.95

Sampler $7.95
Broccoli & Jalapeño Poppers, Mozzarella Sticks, Onion Rings & Chicken Finger

Soup $2.75
Home Made Cole Slaw $ 1.00

Buffalo Wings
6 pieces $6.95 • 12 pieces $8.95

95¢ Extras – Extra Cheese • American • Cooper Sharp • Provolone • Blue Cheese • Lettuce & Tomato • Fresh or Sautéed Green Peppers Garlic • Mushrooms • Broccoli • Avocado • Roasted Red Peppers • Sundried Tomatoes • Barbecue Sauce • Pepperoni • Bacon

No Charge – Sauce • Fried or Raw Onions • Pickles • Relish • Sweet or Hot Peppers • Franks Red Hot Sauce • Horseradish Sauce • Jalapeños

Having a Party?

Party Hoagies: 3 Ft. $51.00 * 6 Ft. $97.00
Italian or Ham & Cheese — Any other meat available at additional cost.6 Foot Hoagies serve approximately 20 people depending on appetite. 3 Foot Hoagies serve approximately 10 people depending on appetite.

Party Steaks: 3 Ft. $115.00 • 6 Ft. upon request.
3 ft. steaks serve approximately 15 people depending upon appetite

Custom Party Trays
Meat, Cheeses, Vegetables, Fruits, Salads, Desserts Please See Manager for Quote.
Two (2) Day Notice & Deposit Required.

Beverages

Fountain Soda $1.50 w/Free refills
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Cherry Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Sierra Mist, Mug Root Beer, Lipton Raspberry Iced Tea, Tropicana Lemonade

Orange, Grapefruit or Tomato Juice $ .95
Fresh Brewed Ices Tea $1.50
Coffee, Tea or Sanka $1.50
Hot Chocolate $1.25

IceCream &Shakes

Bowl - 1 Dip $1.95 2 Dip $2.45 3 Dip $2.95
Chocolate Syrup 25¢

Extra Thick Shake $3.95
Extra Thick Malt $4.05
Floats $4.05
your favorite fountain soda with two scoops of ice cream